A Future of Urban Healthcare
Anarchists have a long-standing tradition of providing medicine to all, so naturally the cities of the future will include autonomous healthcare. Even if libertarian socialist ethics spread regionally or globally, the availability of resources and the environment itself will be significant factors in how this care is provided. Climate change will make some regions less hospitable to human life either through unsurvivable heat or a lack of arable land. Technosolutionism may allow us to continue to manufacture high tech tools, or we may find that conserving the environment limits the extraction necessary for such tech. These factors will change how cities and healthcare look, as will regional variations, so accurate predictions of the future would need to be tremendously complex as well as laden with caveats. Predicting which paths humanity will most likely take can at times be an exercise in pragmatic fatalism, so instead of looking at ways humanity will scrape by during widespread desertification and deadly heat waves, let’s instead look at how humanity will thrive despite climate change. Sometimes we need a little optimism, and this is an example of how some regions might organize.
Current Conditions
Three key constraints that shape modern healthcare are the initial capital required to become a healthcare practitioner, the restriction of intellectual property, and the artificial scarcity of materials needed for medicine. These constraints exist in their most obscene forms in neo-liberal “free” markets like the United States where healthcare is privatized and even those with insurance often cannot afford routine checkups or the costs of minor accidents. Some may point to States like the United Kingdom with the NHS as examples the sort of welfare provided by social-democracy. At its best, it still is rife with hierarchy and discrimination, and at present it has been actively hamstrung by right-wing austerity. Even the most allegedly socialist States have elements of privatization or back-channel prioritization based on class or party standing.
The ability to train to become the lowest grade paramedic still excludes the economically disadvantaged either through the cost of certification or the time that must be allocated away from paid work for the courses. Becoming a doctor is even more stacked in favor of the privileged as the decade-long process is generally dependent on the class-correlated quality of secondary education and the ability to pay for an undergraduate degree and medical school. This, along with discrimination during education in the workplace, leads to some demographics being significantly underrepresented among medical practitioners.
Medicine is an ivory tower where it is exceedingly difficult for people to research their own conditions or the conditions present within their community. Textbooks and papers are restricted, and much of the “free” information found on the internet funnels people towards profitable solutions or is downright medically inaccurate. Individuals become reliant on the authority of institutional medicine to dispense knowledge and care, and when they seek it out on their own, there are high odds they end up reading pseudo-science.
Even the most well-intentioned doctors with the most connection to their communities are restricted by the time per patient and the materials that are accessible. Private or nationalized insurance may not pay for treatments that they have not authorized, and medicine and equipment can be exorbitantly expensive. Resources for research and development are directed toward profitable solutions, so medication for rare diseases may never be developed. Life-saving medications, such as antivenoms, may even be discontinued because they are not profitable to produce.
Budgets also restrict the availability of staff in medical centers. Large, centralized facilities have a regular stream of incoming patients and thus can justify staffing of entire departments for emergency care. Smaller medical facilities in rural and frontier environments may lack interested practitioners, and when practitioners are interested, there are insufficient patients being billed to pay for multiple physicians and surgeons to be on standby for care.
Lack of community trust in medicine is not a direct constraint, but it is a product of discrimination or the willingness to exploit vulnerable populations, and it negatively impacts how certain populations relate to and receive medical care. This mistrust may exist within a demographic due to repeated negative experiences with the healthcare system. Other times it may exist because of historical medical abuses such as forced sterilizations or non-consensual experimentation against one’s demographic. Sometimes it’s simply because medical professionals are outsiders to a community and are viewed with some skepticism.
Restructuring and Emergence
Systems do not change at the drop of a pin; radical restructuring takes time. If healthcare institutions and universities take a decade to adapt to a world without capitalism, the boon of new doctors would not be working on their own in a new system for some 15-20 years past some epochal inflection point. While many benefits of truly socialized healthcare would be seen before that, total change and societal adaptation would take significant time. Instead of looking at the moments of radical transformation, let us instead consider the shape of these systems as they settle into new configurations.
De-Urbanization
Following the collapse of capital, there would be a lifting of the economic impetus that drives people to and holds people in urban centers. Some might immigrate to cities, but many more would leave. In the present world, there is a proportional oversaturation of medical practitioners in urban environments compared to suburban, rural, and frontier environments. Among the expatriates from the cities would be many doctors returning to their former communities to bring higher quality medicine, having originally left because of better education and (in some regions) better pay. This would start the process of decentralization of medicine, both in terms of knowledge and facilities, away from urban centers.
Decentralization can, however, be at odds with environmental conservation, and in the case of medicine, some specialized equipment relies on the extraction of rare earth metals. Additionally, specialists are needed to operate said equipment and interpret their results. Maximum care trauma centers, even equipment aside, require many disciplines to care for the different injuries of a polytrauma patient. One patient alone can require multiple surgeons in different fields and multiple emergency care physicians, such as a patient who was in a building collapse who has an intracranial hemorrhage, bone fractures, and significant burns to their skin. Full decentralization, in the sense that every community can provide all health services its residents require, may not be possible because of these constraints, so the adaptation would be stronger federation between urban and non-urban locations. It may be infeasible to get specialists and equipment to more remote locations, and while telemedicine can provide some services, one of the main obstacles to care would be patient logistics. Networks would develop for moving patients in need of long-term care and complex emergency care toward centralized nodes with appropriate staff and facilities. Centers for treating rare and complex injuries and illnesses would remain somewhat centralized, though not necessarily in urban centers.
For emergencies, expedient care is necessary to save lives and body functionality. As a simple example, the survival rate increases and disability rate decreases as the time from the onset of a stroke to treatment decreases, often abbreviated by the phrase “time is brain.” Moving patients to centralized nodes is not simply a matter of getting them there, but how fast. Increased centralization means increased transit times. Additionally, individuals also tend to select for convenience, and medicine is no different. Basic emergency services and general practitioners will decentralize at greater rates than specialist medicine to accommodate these wants.
This flow of medical potential is not specifically urban to rural but rather core to periphery. Rural areas within the States of the imperial core have relative privilege to other regions globally, but within the States themselves they are still at the periphery. There is currently inequality in who has access to healthcare with the best care being provided to the elite in urban centers in the States of the imperial core. To address the injustices in access to healthcare distribution more globally, cities may see a decrease in the availability of the highest level of care as equipment and practitioners move to regions that have traditionally suffered from exploitation, imperialism, and embargoes.
The average level of care received within a city would still increase in accessibility and quality along with the average level of care globally. Medical practitioners working in an urban environment have the advantage of a steady stream of patients with varied conditions. This, along with other knowledgeable colleagues, lets them learn and continuously practice their skills. If medical staff decentralize away from urban centers, those working in rural and frontier environments may see a lower number of conditions and use skills they’ve learned less frequently. Skills that are not used are lost, and practitioners will still somehow need to maintain their knowledge and skills through use.
Systems will emerge to help prevent skill loss in rural environments with a lower volume of patients in certain disciplines. Practitioners currently self-limit to treatments and procedures they feel they are qualified to give even if they are certified or legally allowed to perform others. To help practitioners who live in remote environments retain their skills, networks among colleagues would allow them to temporarily come to urban centers for continued education and practical skill training. Much of modern society promotes individuals permanently settling in one location with one (or multiple) fixed places of work, but with this constraint removed, practitioners may be able to periodically travel to cities to work until they feel competent with a skill again.
Community Medicine
Decentralization is not just the splitting of a small number large nodes into a large number of small nodes that retain isolation or hierarchical structures between them. It means creating a web of many interconnected individuals and organizations that work together both independently and symbiotically.
One of the ways that medicine is currently structurally held apart from the community is a lack of gradation and interconnectedness of care. When one needs regular or non-emergency care, they see their primary care provider (PCP), typically a physician or nurse practitioner. If the PCP cannot handle the issue, they give verbal instructions how to find specialist care, often “Go to the emergency department” or “find a podiatrist and ask them about it.” There is no handoff, and there is a significant step, both psychologically and in terms of level of care, in moving from a PCP to a hospital. And when a patient is discharged from a hospital or sent home from a specialist with instructions, they are often on their own to continue their care.
The decentralization efforts will also happen intra-city, and care will move away from large hospitals to community medicine with smaller practices and family doctors. Where the were jumps between levels of care, and where these departments and specializations were kept separate, there will instead be a continuum of care that allows easy transitions from lower level care to the highest level of care and back down again. This ingress into the medical process might start with those who are outside of the traditional domain of medicine such as community healers, those who take care of others or are sought out for advice. Care might end here where a bandage and antimicrobial ointment is applied, or it may be escalated to community nurses. The individual with a funny looking mole might then be ushered to a dermatologist for further consultation. When a patient starts working their way down the gradient from more intense and specialized care to basic care, there would be still be continued care instead of abrupt termination of care. Discharged patients could have access to ambulatory nursing or even short-term, non-stigmatized assisted living facilities to help them easily recover or simply have frequent and easy access to physicians.
When bureaucracy does not impose top-down order on medical care, practitioners can self-organize and build their own networks to handle patient care. At each step along the way, from community healer to neurosurgeon, the practitioners would develop networks of trust and connection. Where previous the interfaces were purely between Facility Alpha and Department Beta, or even the abstract idea of “some oncologist somewhere else,” individuals would become more familiar with those around them giving them time to help spread their knowledge. When a healer sends a local to a dermatologist for that funny looking mole, and it turns out to have been cancerous, communicating this from the physician or the patient back to the healer encourages this cooperation.
The removal of barriers to training would mean more practitioners, which means a lower patient to practitioner ratio. Even within the current system, this would mean practitioners who are more alert and less burned out leading to better patient outcomes. An improved ratio gives practitioners more time per patient, and this can foster the development of connections with patients that previously was much more difficult. This connection and the closer proximity to the community members being cared for can make medicine more holistic. More capacity and less restrictions to medicine would mean that those without access to medicine in a capitalist world would be able to receive regular treatment. There would be a bond between healthcare workers and the community in which they operate.
Because the ability to practice medicine would not be gated by class, medical practitioners would have a similar demographic distribution as the general population, age aside. The groups that would see the highest improvement of care and positive outcomes from ailments would be those that are currently most marginalized. Trans doctors would be better able to provide tailored care for trans patients, and likewise with other demographics such as non-dominant ethnicities or those with disabilities. A long-term effect of this demographic shift within medicine would be medical research moving away from treating middle-aged white men as the “normal” on which all medicine is based. When a practitioner doesn’t share the demographic of their patients, they would still be able to provide better care due to better education and clinical research.
Racism, misogyny, transmisia, fatmisia, and other prejudices don’t disappear because of the introduction of socialist programs, so shitbag healthcare workers would still exist. However, what would also exist is actual patient choice in their healthcare provider instead of being stuck with whoever had an appointment available or was assigned by a bureaucratic insurance company. Prejudiced and abusive people could be more easily avoided.
The positive effects of better representation in the medical field and real patient choice would be further magnified by the democratization of medical knowledge when the walled gardens of medical papers and textbooks are made open to the public. Individuals would be able to research their symptoms and take notes to their healthcare providers. Instead of the information flow being unidirectional from practitioner to patient, it would be bidirectional and collaborative. Practitioners who beat down patients with the cudgel of authority will lose out on patients, but because their ability to survive is not dependent on an income, they wouldn’t be driven out of business by competition in the classical sense. They would still continue to practice medicine, but they might only have a few patients who aren’t impacted by their prejudices.
Medical practitioners who are more available to their patients who themselves are more educated on health makes for more trust in medicine as a practice. Visiting a doctor would be less like scheduling a time-boxed procedure and more akin to dropping by your local market to talk about what’s in season and new recipes. The barrier to contacting healthcare workers would be reduced, and this would make it easy to incorporate regular healthcare into one’s life.
Just as not everyone is a foodie who wants to eat only the freshest and most nutritious meals, and not everyone wants to discuss culinary trends or the provenance of their produce, not every patient will want to have long conversations with healthcare providers or undergo involved and time-consuming treatments. To continue the metaphor, some people eat quick meals just to get calories into their body, and likewise some will still want to only get a bare minimum of medical care to patch up their body when things go awry. Because of the cost and effort required to book even a simple checkup, many forego basic medical care as it’s “not worth it.” Lowering the barriers to entry for medicine by increasing the availability of practitioners and creating more graduated steps will help those who might have been historically excluded from medicine receive both regular basic care and specialist care for their ailments.
Depending on one’s region, healthcare work can be seen as a task assigned to professionals, a task that only occurs at known time periods in one’s life. Infants, the pregnant, the recuperating, and the elderly are often pushed off to be cared for by someone else as these conditions are seen as aberrations to some “normal” state of affairs. Part of this is due to the nuclear family structure of the so-called west, but more generally it is a result of the restrictions on time and resources in an atomized culture. Some of this can be attributed to conscious “rugged individualism,” and some is the result of individuals prioritizing themselves while struggling to survive in an actively hostile world, even if they wished to be able to care for others. Most importantly, perfect health is the expectation, and ailments are moralized and seen as personal failures. This care work is offloaded on to others, and it tends to fall on people who are read as women and low-paid individuals.
With total liberation, the norm would not be to split work across gender, racial, or class lines, and there would be external pressure for all to contribute to care via a default expectation that work is spread evenly. Mutual aid as an ethos would be cultivated, and this would lead to an internal drive to help others whereby one would see a need that is unmet, and they would then take the initiative to meet it. If members of a society do not assume that both themselves and others must be perpetually self-reliant, the significant work of tending to others, such as later in life or due to illness, would not be viewed as some burden to bear but rather as that which one must do for society to remain functional and healthy.
When medicine is not rigidly tiered and set apart from the communities it serves, healthcare would become a community effort again. Individuals with more time to themselves would still feel that they can pursue their passions and leisures instead of spending the scant few free hours they have per week taking care of others. The work required by individuals to care for their loved ones, neighbors, and yes even the disliked misers would be reduced by freely available doctors and nurses. Care-takers would exist to check in on others and might assist with their daily activities, but such roles might only exist for those who need a high level of care. Assisted living facilities would be able to be more embedded within communities, and even when labor-intensive, long-term care is required, it would not be separated by significant physical distance or the mental distance of relegating the infirm to some void where they can languish and perish without disturbing the hale and hearty. To borrow the community defense slogan of the present, in they future they might say “we keep us healthy.”
Much the way start-of-life and end-of-life care is relegated to the margins of our thought, mental health is often cleaved from physical health as if the two can be reasonably separated, and this is typically directly enforced by current healthcare bureaucracies. Simply by the abolition of capitalism, many of the direct causes of poor mental health would be removed, but still mental healthcare will always be desired. Carceral psychiatric hospitals, like prisons, would be destroyed, and with the abolition of the police, the response to a mental health crisis would not be one of violence but one of patience, understanding, and accommodation. Because there can be physiological causes of mental health ailments, physical examinations prior to care would still be the norm, but the accessibility of physical healthcare would not make this a hurdle. More generally, spaces (figuratively and otherwise) would be set aside where people could find comfort, free of the burden of becoming “productive” again. Even just by the very nature of reduced work, individuals would have more time to check in on the well-being of their friends before moments of crisis arise. The aid we provide each other wouldn’t be reactive; it wouldn’t just be the response to depression or mania. It would be proactive, and individuals would actively engage with one another to, where possible, root out the causes of poor mental health. Individuals would not be only looking out for themselves and those in their immediate networks, but rather work would be done so that all can find great elation, including creating space and accommodation for neurodivergences.
Societal Effects
Due to the time and resource restrictions of capitalism, many people do not address problems in their lives until they become critical. Presently, many people treat their health a as sort of object that breaks, and they only seek medical care when it needs to be repaired. When medicine is free for all, when it is accessible, when the choices that lead to good health are made possible, many people will change their relation to their own health from a tool that breaks into a resource that can be cultivated. What we call “self-care” within radical spaces now is often a bare minimum to keep us functioning as workers so we can pay rent or as activists so we can continue fighting. Holistic care that comes from the community in its entirety will become normalized, and individuals will be able to set out time to true personal joy and care, both on their own and with others.
When family doctors and other medical professionals don’t exist aside from the community, but rather as a part of it, how we relate to health will change, and in particular with respect to the creation of new life and death. These two parts of human existence are heavily medicalized where non-practitioners rely on practitioners to guide them through the medical parts of these human experiences, away from the communities and in culturally-sterile ways. Our ability to experience the joys of new life and to cope with death are stunted and degraded because we cannot experience them with others socially.
Birth could be a moment celebrated with cherished ones in one’s own home. Family and friends could be part of this process and be present to help with the initial responsibilities of child rearing. The requirement to work would not exist, and the formative years of a child’s life could be spent with far more attentive care.
Humans would learn to cope with death and loss by it being more present in their communities. Instead of the elderly dying in their apartments alone or equally alone in assisted living facilities, they would reach the end of their lives more gracefully and surrounded by others. The experience of the death of others would not be such an alien experience, and consequently the unexpected loss of other loved ones would be less traumatic. The entire way we would relate to death would change. This isn’t to say transhumanist efforts to defeat death wouldn’t continue through therapies or cybernetics, but earnest discussion about death wouldn’t be so taboo, and we would more healthily learn to deal with it.
As communities learn to care for themselves and set aside space, and as they are not restricted by capital, cities will change their physical form to promote health. More parks would exist, but with less reliance on cars, more streets would be park-like and have trees and gardens. Strict zoning would put more amenities within walking distance. When work isn’t coerced, people will find more ways to be joyful and active. Spaces to exercise, even if just by walking, will spring up to meet demands as will places for individuals to relax and socialize with each other. Living made joyful and nourishing will, even with no other changes to medicine, decrease disease and increase life expectancy.
New Tensions
Presently, for many disciplines there is one governing body per State that issues certificates saying that the bearer has met some criteria or possesses some capabilities or knowledge, and such a certificate enables them to perform their profession. These governing bodies originated as a means of protecting their members’ statuses by gatekeeping entrance into the field, but in part they claim to protect the public from malpractice. Following the abolition of the State and capital, these bodies will cease to exist, but it’s often said that “safety rules are written in blood,” so some new structures will emerge to protect the public and ensure high quality of services.
Physical spaces are loci of many activities and forms of organizing, and hospitals by their centralized nature will have some inherent ability to self-regulate. A seasoned expert can spot a fraud very quickly, and the mutual oversight between colleagues would provide checks to ensure that all are acting in ways that do not endanger patients either through outdated or esoteric practices. One of the ways anarchist organizations keep themselves in check — particularly from accumulating power — is by splintering, merging, and reforming. This fluidity is not possible when such large physical spaces and organizational structures exist, and internal conflicts about what constitutes legitimate medical practices or even the power struggles of micro-tyrants could lead to hospitals fracturing along department or theoretical/ideological lines.
Other medical practices that do not require such large, connected, specialized spaces — such as general practitioners, dentists, or gynecologists — will not have the same builtin capacity for oversight. Many general practices have only one or two physicians plus a few nurses, and there is the possibility that several untrained, apathetic, or otherwise unscrupulous individuals could come together and practice improper or outdated medicine.
To offer some proof of competency, medical guilds might arise to provide the same sort of assurances covered by current medical licensing boards. They might provide guidelines for what is expected from medical training or what practices fall outside of accepted medical science. As science is not some singular truth that everyone inevitably converges upon, there would be many guilds with many — yet overlapping — criteria for education and praxis. These guilds might be local to a region, but they would likely federate with others or have presence in multiple regions.
When practitioners move between regions, hospitals and practices could trust the practitioner’s previous hospital or guild and therefore have a starting point of elevated trust in the practitioner themself. Or, there may be no such guilds and trust would have to be built up at the individual level wherein practitioners who transfer go through a brief period where they are shadowed by a known trusted colleague.
Hospitals and guilds would allow patients to check the ways in which their provider is qualified. Because of the historic nature of organizations protecting themselves from criticism and sheltering those who cause harm, independent watchdog groups might also arise to inform the public about medical safety. These might be staffed by doctors or simply people who collect reviews and complaints and investigate them.
The medical field currently allows for medical malpractice insofar as chiropractors are allowed to call themselves “doctor,” and homeopathy is still widely practiced by people who have completed medical school. During the COVID-19 pandemic, we’ve seen huge amounts of medical professionals be allowed to continue practicing medicine while being anti-vax. Anarchism alone is not the cure for misinformation, and in particular medical misinformation. Pseudo- and anti-scientific beliefs are widespread in current anarchist spaces, and while in the future there would be better access to information and fewer financial incentives for pedalling snake oil, these trends would certainly continue.
What new tensions would exist is the possibility of factions directly countering each other. Guilds could denounce each other, hospitals could refuse doctors from certain guilds, and smaller practices could speak out against each other without running afoul of libel and slander laws. When a group practices or pedals something that causes community harm — like anti-vax “science,” the overuse of antibiotics, or dangerous procedures — they could be directly countered and disrupted. Practitioners who impair public health through poor practices, or even by spreading ideas that cause people to make choices not based in scientific medicine could face intra-org or community sanctions. Watchdog groups could take direct action to shutdown anti-vax practices to preempt disease outbreak, and just as much esoteric doctors and patients could fight back to defend their rights to practice anti-science. A theoretical ground for these guilds to disrupt those engaging in anti-science is that medical practice is predicated on the informed consent of patients, and if one is informed by — what the guild believes to be — lies, then they are not able to give genuine consent.
Just as within modern anarchist thought, there are competing ideas and centuries of debate have not narrowed us down to one set of practices, medicine of the future would see similar struggles but with more possibility of dynamic shifts and confrontations when a singular controlling body is removed. The democratization of information does not stop misinformation, and free association would allow those who practice woo to come together and reject science, possibly leading to divergent medical currents like we see today.
Closing Remarks
Much of the way we think of the future of healthcare is in terms of the current system, only “socialist-er.” In our imaginations, the same structures tend to exist, only better funded, with happier staff, and more positive outcomes. We are limited by how deeply we are embedded in capitalism, and even this essay may seem laughably unimaginative by anarchists who read it in the future. It also carries all the biases of its author (a white, uni-educated, abled, read-as-man person in Europe), and while it attempts to account for how others experience medicine currently and how they might in the future, there are of course (to its author) unknown unknowns, so naturally there are gaps with respect to medical traumas and healthcare and its norms in other regions. Other cultures, now and in the future, have different ideas about medicine and different ways they fit medicine into their societies. This is no blueprint, just some imaginings of how some cities and regions may look.
Another world is possible. We can start to build the cities of the future in the cities of the present, and we can apply non-hierarchical organizing principles and mutual aid to our current communities. Doctors and nurses can be recruited into street medicine collectives, and autonomous spaces can incorporate community medicine into their programs. Healthcare from below can be built starting today. We do not have to wait until after The Rev™. The future is now. Go out and make it.